Field guide

Non-conformance reports, explained for site teams.

An NCR, or non-conformance report, records work, materials or processes that do not meet a stated project requirement. Follow the project quality plan for notification, disposition, verification and approval. This guide explains the record and distinguishes the formal NCR process from SiteWarden’s punch list and defect workflow.

Product and record-keeping guidance by SiteWarden. Read the linked source in its stated jurisdiction and project context, and use the project’s authorised people for contract, technical or compliance decisions. How these guides are reviewed.

What counts as a non-conformance

A non-conformance is any output that fails to meet a stated requirement: concrete that misses its specified strength, waterproofing installed without the specified membrane, work that skips a hold point in the inspection and test plan, or materials substituted without approval.

The trigger is the requirement, not the visible quality of the work. Work can look fine and still be non-conforming; that is exactly why the NCR exists as a formal record rather than a site conversation.

What a good NCR includes

An NCR is a record other people act on — the subcontractor rectifying it, the engineer approving a disposition, the client’s quality representative auditing it later. Vague NCRs create disputes; specific ones close.

  • A unique NCR number, the date, and who raised it.
  • The requirement that was not met: specification clause, drawing reference, standard, or ITP hold point.
  • A specific description of the non-conforming work with location and photos.
  • The proposed disposition: rework, repair, use-as-is with engineering approval, or reject.
  • Who is responsible for the rectification and the date it is required by.
  • Verification and sign-off once the disposition is completed.

NCR versus defect: same loop, different trigger

A defect is work that is faulty or incomplete — usually found on inspection walks and handled through the defect list. An NCR records a failure against a stated requirement and often carries a formal disposition process, including the possibility of accepting the work with engineering approval.

The loops overlap heavily: both need a structured record, photos, an owner, a rectification, and verified closure. Many items could be raised either way, and on most projects the NCR register and the defect list run side by side — NCRs for specification and process failures, the defect list for quality items found on inspection.

Track open NCRs and record authorised closure

Keep unresolved NCRs on the register with the current status, responsible person, proposed or approved disposition and next action. Record the completed work, verification and authorised approval before closure. An open record makes the unresolved issue visible; it must not be hidden to make the register look complete.

Queensland Transport and Main Roads’ MRTS50 clauses 10.2 and 11 illustrate notification, corrective action and quality-record requirements for road infrastructure. Apply the requirements of your own project. SiteWarden supports the associated punch list or defect finding, photos, responsibility, status and reports; keep formal NCR approvals and dispositions in the required quality system.

A few more details

Common questions.

Still weighing it up? Talk to our team.

What does NCR stand for in construction?

Non-conformance report (sometimes non-conformance record): the formal document raised when work, materials, or processes do not meet the specification, drawings, standards, or quality system requirements.

Who can raise an NCR?

Typically anyone in the quality chain: site engineers, supervisors, quality managers, superintendents, or client representatives. The project quality plan sets who reviews and approves dispositions.

What is the difference between an NCR and a defect?

A defect is faulty or incomplete work, usually found on inspection and handled through the defect list. An NCR records a failure against a stated requirement and carries a formal disposition — rework, repair, use-as-is with approval, or reject.

How is an NCR closed out?

Complete the authorised disposition, verify the result against the requirement and retain the evidence and required approval. Until then, keep the NCR open with its responsible person and next action. Follow the project quality plan for who can approve closure.

See it on your next site walk

Bring your list.
We’ll walk you through it.

Unfinished work, defects and the details in between. See how the current app captures, organises and reports on them.

Book a Demo